Evaluating Investment Alternatives
About the Activity
This activity teaches kids about different investment options and what each one means for their money. They’ll also answer questions to check their understanding and help them think about investing.
Note: Youth should complete the activity Banking Your Money on how to calculate interest before doing this activity.
Topic: Financial Literacy
Estimated Time: 30 Minutes
What You'll Need
- Pen or Pencil
- An internet-connected smartphone, tablet or computer
- A calculator
- First, familiarize yourself with the definitions of the types of investments we'll discuss in this activity:
- Basic Savings Account: The most fundamental saving tool, these are associated with low minimum balances and few restrictions, but also low interest rates.
- High-Yield Savings Account: These have higher interest rates than typical savings accounts, but often require higher minimum balances and have more restrictions.
- Certificates of Deposit (CD): An investment tool in which money is invested for a fixed amount of time; they typically have higher interest rates that are fixed, but also come with penalties for early withdrawals.
- Credit Union: A nonprofit-making money cooperative whose members can borrow from pooled deposits at low interest rates.
- Mutual Fund: An investment tool that pools the money of many investors and invests it in stocks, bonds, and money market assets, or other securities.
- Imagine you have $500 in cash that you want to save for a family vacation next year. Now that you’ve read about the different investment types, think about how investing this money can allow it to grow before you plan to use it.
- Look at the options for investing your money below. How much money will you have after one year for each of the following investment options at these fictitious financial institutions.Use the formula APY= (1 + r/n )n – 1, where “r” is interest rate and “n” is number of years to determine how much interest you’d earn, or complete Banking Your Money to learn more about calculating interest.
- State Bank Regular Savings Account. This bank has a minimum deposit of $100 required,
and a $500 minimum balance required to avoid a $4 monthly service fee. 2.75% APY.
- ABC Investments. 12-month Certificate of Deposit, or CD, with no minimum deposit. No
monthly fees, but you have to pay a fee if you withdraw the money before 12 months.
3.3% APY. Learn more about CDs by doing the Save Smart activity.
- Big Bank Premium Savings Account. No minimum deposit or minimum balance
if you are under 18. Unlimited access to make deposits and withdrawals. No monthly
service fee if you are under 18. 0.15% APY.
- Local Credit Union Vacation Club Savings. Minimum deposit of $0.01 and minimum
balance of $0.01. No monthly fees. 0.35% APY.
- XYZ Mutual Fund. Minimum deposit of $500. No monthly fees. Average annual return rate of 5%. Note that mutual fund returns are not guaranteed (meaning that some years you
might earn more, some years less, and some years you may even lose money), but this particular fund has historically averaged a 5% return each year over the long term.
- Separately, think of three companies you’ve heard of. Use Google to search the stock price for those companies. If you get no results, that may mean it’s a private company, which means you can’t buy and sell its stock. Try again with a new company until you get results. Use the market summary in the search results to examine each company’s stock price over different periods of time. What do you notice about the last day, week, month, 6 months, year, 5 years and maximum about of time? Does investing in individual stock seem more or less risky than other options? Learn more about stocks by watching this VIDEO.
- Imagine it’s a month before the vacation (11 months since you made your investment), and you want to start withdrawing money. Which institutions would apply a fee for withdrawing before a year?
- Now, discuss: Based on your calculations above, what are your best options for investing your money for 6 months or less? A year? Five years or longer?
Questions to Engage Youth
- Which investment options increased your money the most?
- Which ones increased your money the least?
- What financial risks are associated with each investment type?
- Why is it a good idea to invest your money, instead of just storing it as cash?
- What factors are most important to you when selecting an investment option?
- Why is it important to compare different investment options?
- Why should you keep your money invested for as long as possible?
- What would happen to each of your investments in the event of an economic downturn?
You have options for investing your money, no matter how much you have. Many investment institutions have low or no minimum deposit requirements and some even offer rewards and perks for investing. Once you set your financial goals, investing wisely can help you reach them faster.
Download the Evaluating Investment Alternatives Activity
Brought to you by:
No endorsement of these supporters' products or services is granted or implied by 4‑H. TD Ameritrade® commentary is for educational purposes only. Member SIPC. All investing involves risks, including risk of loss.